Monday, 16 November 2026

Emerging from the fog, with three pertinent questions

Last weekend was very foggy. Last Saturday night I had the dubious pleasure of watching Altrincham trying to win a penalty shoot out after drawing their first round FA Cup game against Notts County. Altrincham lost I think, although I couldn’t be sure as I couldn’t see the goals. If Altrincham had won this game it would have been the 18th league side that they had defeated in the FA Cup in their history. No other non-league side comes anywhere close to their record. This was all I knew of Altrincham before I came to live their 16 years go. I remember seeing them each year during the football results on Grandstand. It is one of the many mysteries of life why Altrincham are the “David’s” or do I mean “Elahanan” to the “Goliath’s” of football. They almost were again last Saturday night.

There are many strange anomalies in sport. One great mystery seems to be Leeds United being far superior at night, especially at home, but rarely winning if a game kicks off before 3pm. Until they beat Spurs last Saturday they had not done so for 21 games, that had kicked off before 3pm.

Life is full of mysteries and synchronicities. Maybe not tales completely of the unexpected, but unexpected encounters and questions. I am often left gifts from mysterious angels. I receive unexpected invitations. I was invited to meet a friend who was visiting the area on last Monday morning. It was a brief encounter as they were passing through, but a joyful one. Molly was particularly pleased to see them once again. They asked me some very pertinent questions about one or two things. A little later I walked through the fog toward the park and bumped into a woman I know who recently got a little Maltepoo. She had always had spaniels before and always wants to talk about little dogs. She also engaged me in one or two impertinent questions, which I managed to manoeuvre around. She certainly quizzed me.

Over the next 24 hours I lost count of the number of questions, pertinent and impertinent questions of many kinds. I was somewhat puzzled by the quizzing. On Tuesday I bumped into my local poet friend, Oliver James Lomax. We had a lovely conversation about several things, mainly folk in our lives that we are concerned about. Before I left He gave me a gift of his latest book “I Found God Alone And He Was Grieving”. He told me if anyone should be the first to be gifted a copy, then it ought to be me. I left with gratitude in my heart and a head with thoughts of quiz and questions. I told him I was off home to work on something based on Tolstoy’s “Three Questions.” I felt like I had been living them and that I wasn’t alone in this.

In the story by Leo Tolstoy, the king asks 3 questions in order to never fail in anything he might undertake. Those three questions were:

“What is the best time to do each thing? Who are the most important people to work with? What is the most important thing to do at all times?

Now the answers to these questions do not come easy, they often come in the mystery of life. Thay can appear as if from a fog or blown in the wind.

In the story the king gathered wise men, but none of them could satisfy him with their answers. So, the king decided to consult a hermit living in a wood. The King went in disguise. When the king saw the hermit in front of his hut, doing hard work, he pitied the hermit and helped him in what he was doing. He also took care of a wounded man: it turned out that the man was his enemy but they made peace with each other. In the end the hermit answers his 3 questions. The 3 answers were:

“The right time to act is now, the most important person to focus on is the person you are with, and the most important task is to do good to others.” Seems like a simple formula for living, no mystery here.

As I wandered home from the park my head was full of the questions folk had been asking me, both pertinent and impertinent. I must have had quite a quizzical look on my face. I was also thinking of quizzes too as I know Annette would be busily compiling questions for a quiz at the chapel this Sunday. On the way I bumped into Ian and his mum Lynne with Big Alf the giant German Shepherd who was the first dog Molly ever met. Molly and Alf asked each other questions and got their answers with their noses. We walked and talked together and then said farewell and I got on with writing this.

People love quizzes, quizzes of every kind. I remember a friend of mine once being charged with the task of producing one for her local community. She made a big mistake of consulting AI for help. It seems it let her down as some of the answers were incorrect. May that be a warning to all of us.

Quizzes can be very frustrating I know, especially if you know the answer, but for some reason you can’t quite get it to move from your unconscious to the conscious, it is seemingly on the tip of your tongue, but it will not come. Well, here’s a good question for you, what is the word for this? The answer is “Lethologica”. It is the reason that words like “whatchamacallit” and “thingymabob” exist. Helpful, but just try and remember the word “lethologica”, especially when the answer to the question just won’t come. It is amazing what is buried deep there in the recesses of memory.

Now can you guess what all this got me thinking about? Well, it got me thinking about the word “Quiz” and where it came from. Does it mean what it always did? I had my suspicion that it probably doesn’t. I also wondered if there may be lessons in how we may live our lives spiritually alive from this popular human pastime. Can we ask the right questions about life? Can we live in the quiz of life? Can we do as David Whyte suggests learn to ask beautiful questions.

First things first though. What is the answer to the question, where does “quiz” come from?

Well there is a story told, which is likely acrophyll, of a prominent Dublin theatre manager named Richard Daley in the late 18th century. He placed a “wager” (now there’s another word of interesting origin) that he could make up a word of no meaning and that it would become common talk in the city within “twenty-four hours. Now in the course of a day the letters “Q.U.I.Z” were chalked or pasted on the walls of Dublin, and it is said that by the end of the day everyone was talking about it and thus he won the wager.

The story has been disputed, although there was a theartre manager named Richard Daley in the Dublin of the day, it is just suggested that the word was in use before his time. Whatever the word “Quiz’s” origin it has certainly changed in meaning over time. The word originally meant an eccentric person or object. Later it meant “to make fun of” or “one who mocks”. It appears in Charlotte Bronte “The Professor” 1857 “He was not odd – no quiz – yet he resembled no one else I had ever seen before.” As well as Jane Austen’s Northanger Abbey “Where did you get that quiz of a hat? It makes you look like an old witch.” It soon became applied to a person who makes fun or mocks another, or a practical joke. As in Charles Dickens “Martin Chuzzlewit "For goodness sake, Mrs. Todgers," interposed the lively Merry, "don't call him a gentleman. My dear Cherry, Pinch a gentleman! The idea!" "What a wicked girl you are!" cried Mrs. Todgers, embracing her with great affection. "You're quite a quiz I do declare!" By the late nineteenth century it began to morph into our current understanding, referring to test or questions, obviously influenced by words such as “question” and “inquisitive”.

So that is where “quiz” comes from and yes it has certainly changed in meaning over time. Can we learn lessons from this on how we may live our lives spiritually alive from this popular human pastime? Can we ask the right questions about life? Can we live in the quiz of life?

The idea of quizzing or being quizzed is I believe vital to living spiritually alive, to living a life of virtue. To do so requires us to ask questions of life and ourselves, to become inquisitive, to make a quiz out of living, to become skeptics in the truest sense of the word. A sceptic is someone who inquires, who questions, who doubts a truth given unless they explore it themselves. Note the title of the Unitarian publication, that I contribute a column to “The Inquirer”. It seems to me that to Inquire is to quiz, to be a skeptic about “truth”.

The first skeptics were found in ancient Greece. Socrates is the father of Skepticism. For him it was impossible for humans to truly know the absolute truth about anything, that the human mind isn’t designed to do so. As he said “I am the most ignorant man in Athens”. He knew more than anyone else it seems and he truly knew how little knowledge about life he truly had. It is this humility that leads to openness and was also a guard against the hubris of some of the great and the good of the day. Humility with respect to the search for knowledge is the key to skepticism, I wonder if this is still the case today.

Now over time skeptical thinking developed from the idea that it was impossible to truly know anything, to being humbled by how many competing wonderful ideas about life existed and the conclusion that as wonderful as they are, they can’t all be right, thus developing into a study of probabilities. Therefore, to doubt and question is not to be against an idea it is about asking the ultimate questions of existence. This to me is the essence of living spiritually alive, of religious living. A true skeptic is not against things, they are open to the possibility of things. Rene Descartes, considered the father of modern enlightenment thinking, is a wonderful example of this. He decided that in order to arrive at absolute truth, he must discard any belief that could be doubted. He did so until he arrived at a single remaining certainty within himself, the fact that he existed. He could no longer doubt this doubt and from there he was able to build something.

The key to true scepticism is humility with regards to the search for truth, it is the ability to see you are wrong, to actually doubt your doubts. This is what Rousseau did. He could not deny his own existence, “I think therefore I am”. Like Socrates the key is humility which leads to an openness to truth. Sadly, it seems that some folk can never admit to being wrong about anything, due to the fear that it might lead to them to seeing that what they believe is untrue. The truth is though, to echo good old Socrates, none of us ever gains access to the whole truth.

Humility, is always the key in the search for truth. This is wonderfully illustrated in the following piece of wisdom from Anthony DeMello’s “One Minute Wisdom”

"To a visitor who described himself as a seeker after Truth, the teacher said: “If what you seek is Truth, there is one thing you must have above all else.” “I know,” answered the student, “an overwhelming passion for it.” “No,” said the teacher, “an unremitting readiness to admit you may be wrong.”

To seek the truth one needs humility and openness and enough self-esteem to see that we are wrong sometimes and of course the capacity to admit to this. If we cannot, we will not be able to see the truth, even when it is right in front of us. It is so easy to become blinded by what we think we know. We need the openness that comes with true humility, it’s a truth that will set us free.

In John’s Gospel Jesus said “Ye shall know the truth and the truth shall set you free.” Words that are echoed in DeMello’s wisdom shared above. I have discovered that this can only be the case if we are truly quizzical about the truth we think we know, and the truth that is offered to us. Not by accepting the truth we are given but by seeking truth, by asking open questions by being quizzical, by becoming true quiz masters and asking open and humble questions about life. If you want to be a seeker of truth then above everything else what you need is an unremitting readiness to admit that you may be wrong. Once you can see you are wrong about something, admit you are wrong about something, do whatever you can to put right what was once wrong, then you are no longer wrong, you are right.

The key, as Socrates taught, is humility and acceptance that you will never see the whole truth about everything, a humitly that will open us up to deeper and greater truths about, life, ourselves and our world.

It is said that when Isidor Rabi, the 1944 Nobel Prize winner in physics, was interviewed about his achievements, he said he owed it all to his mother. "When we got out of school, all the mothers would ask their children what they had learned that day. My mother would inquire instead, 'What did you ask today in class?'"

So let us all become life’s quiz masters. Let us be humble and open enough to not merely answer the questions that others ask of us, but to learn to ask life’s most important questions. What did you ask today?

Please find below a video devotion based on the material in this "Blogspot"



No comments:

Post a Comment